Episode 12 – Incongruous Things

A little of this, a little of that… This week, Halley preps for Hurricane Harvey, brings us an update on sweet Kaytlynn Cargill, and two WTF stories out of Florida. Karah lays out the suspiciousness that is the Sherri Papini disappearance, and per usual, the girls do some conjecturing. Casefile is featured in OPP (Other People’s Podcasts) this week, and of course, Halley HAS to talk about episode one of The Disappearance of Natalee Holloway.

BONUS: The girls share their experiences with the eclipse and the lottery.

Eclipse Arrest

Stripper Stabs Cannibal Boyfriend

Sherri Papini

Casefile – Hosted By Anonymous

Episode 11 – Strong Opinions, Limited Facts

This week, PTTC starts out by getting personal, as Halley and Karah each share a recent creepy-old-guy interaction. Then Halley fan-girls over T.Swift’s $1 court victory for all of womankind and gets all the goosebumps over the Natalee Holloway news, and Karah takes us into the depths of the thwarted Oklahoma bombing attempt and the controversial tactics behind it.

Taylor Swift

Joshua Phillips Update

Natalee Holloway

Foiled OKC Bombing Attempt

Episode 10 – Was it a Subaru?

A badass and brawlers and bears, oh my! This week, Halley introduces you to a Cobb County mama with sass and good aim, a couple of feisty females in Dallas, and another unusual car thief. Karah tells us a Tulsa tale of the punishment not fitting the crime, and then takes us on a detour to Westeros (SPOILER ALERT) to discuss what’s on the whole world’s mind.

ALSO: A quick look at The Docket and what’s going on with Joshua Phillips, Michelle Carter, and Usher.

Story Links:

Under Review: Joshua Phillips

Usher’s Got it Bad

Ursine Joy Ride

Tulsa Fireworks Stand Shooting

Cobb County Mom

Bishop Arts Brawl

Episode 9 – Did Nobody Swipe Right?

This episode will probably leave you with more questions than answers… Like, how much Odor Eaters does it take to cover up “rotting body”? How does a kindergartner navigate an intersection? Does Cosmo Dinardo not understand what Facebook is for? How can you own up to eight felonies, but not admit to being fired? And after Halley and Karah speculate their odds, you may be asking yourself how you’d fare in lockup.

PLUS: Some Alabama prisoners get a taste of freedom, and it is… sticky.


Odor Eaters Cover-Up

Tiny Car Thieves

Cosmo Dinardo’s Facebook Posts

Toronto Man’s Web of Lies

Great Peanut Butter Escape

Episode 8 – What a Depressing Database

In this week’s episode, Halley geeks out over typewriters and escape rooms, the girls talk through the tragic timeline of Tim Piazza’s bid night death and discuss the culpability of frat boys, and Karah lightens it up with some Rocky Mountain mischief makers.

The Graybar Hotel

Penn State/Beta Theta Pi

Baaaa-ad Actors

Episode 7 – I Was Gonna Eat Some Nachos…

Karah delves into the story of America’s newest serial killer, Cosmo DiNardo, and walks us through the horrific events of his most nefarious week. Meanwhile, Halley refuses to admit she was wrong about Alexa, is still obsessed with Uber crimes, and of course, can’t resist talking about OJ. Oh, also: meth-heads doing meth-heady things.

Stories Discussed

UPDATE: Alexa Can’t Call the Cops

OJ Simpson (Latest)

Uber Murder

Lady Bites Johnson

Killer Cosmo

OPP: Other People’s Podcasts

Tapped from Feral Audio

Lore hosted by Aaron Manhnke

Convicted hosted by Brooke Gittings

Up and Vanished hosted by Payne Lindsey

Episode 6 – Iffy is All We’ve Got

90% laughter, 10% profanity… Halley and Karah really let down their hair this week. Struggling to push through vacation blues and not ready to face the world’s depravity, the girls stick to the lighter side of true crime — an all-night prison riot, the “Groundhog Day” of trials, and a lot of entertainment news: a new mini-series Halley is geeking out about, Chip and Joanna being sued because Waco sucks, and of course, OPP (Other People’s Podcasts). And almost no one dies.


Alexa Calls the Cops

Prison Riot

YouTube Prank Gone Wrong

Shannon Kepler Trial #3

Natalee Holloway

Fixer Upper Buyer Drama


Up & Vanished hosted by Payne Lindsey

Episode 5 – BONUS EPISODE: From the Cutting Room Floor

Pretty much every week, Halley tries to sneak in just ONE more story than there is time for. Ipso facto, every week, Karah has to cut a story prior to publishing. Since the girls are on vacay this week, feast your ears on a minisode mashup of what DIDN’T make it into the first four episodes.

Episode 4 – Not THAT Tina Fey

This week, the girls get philosophical AND actually do some research! They tackle the devastating disappearance of Kaytlynn Cargill (and what an AMBER Alert is and isn’t) and try to sandwich that heaviness with hilarity: yet another toe thief, the Cruella deVil of Great Danes, and Halley (poorly) impersonating her mom. ALSO: Karah updates us on Making a Murderer, and Halley postulates that true crime lovers are smarter than everyone else.

Amarillo Stand-Off

Canadian Toe Thief

Making a Murderer Updates- Brendan Dassey & Steven Avery

Bedford, TX Child Disappearance

Great Dane Puppy Mill Mansion

Podcast Rec’s

In The Dark – Hosted by Madeleine Baran

Binge Mode: Game of Thrones – From TheRinger.Com

Episode 3 – Georgia, Good Enough

Join Halley and Karah this week as they fall in love with a heroic hottie, learn what “El Chapo” means (and where he is now), and get a little bit jealous of a (foiled) murder-for-hire plot. And, of course, they discuss the Cosby mistrial and the conviction of Michelle Carter. BONUS: Karah writes a country song and Halley does an SNL cheer.

Cosby Analysis

Michelle Carter

Houston Murder-For-Hire: Patch.com & KPRC Houston

Georgia Inmate Escape: CNN & NY Daily News

Cartel Wives: Chicago Sun Times & NY Daily News

Justifiable Homicide

Book Rec’s

It’s Always the Husband by Michele Campbell

Podcast Rec’s

S-Town hosted by Brian Reed

Mystery Show hosted by Starlee Kine. Case #3 Belt Buckle is especially amazing.